Unfair Dismissal in Scotland: What You Need to Know

5 April 2026

Unfair Dismissal in Scotland: What You Need to Know

Losing your job is one of the most difficult experiences anyone can face at work. When it happens suddenly or feels unjust, many people in Scotland are left wondering whether it was handled fairly and what rights they actually have.

This article explains what unfair dismissal means, when a dismissal may be considered unfair, what a fair dismissal process should look like, and what steps you can take if you believe you have been unfairly dismissed.

What is unfair dismissal?

Unfair dismissal happens when an employer ends your employment without a fair reason or without following a fair procedure.

Most employees in Scotland gain protection against unfair dismissal after two years of continuous service, although there are important exceptions where protection applies from day one.

To dismiss someone fairly, an employer must:

  • have a valid reason for dismissal
  • follow a fair procedure
  • act reasonably in the circumstances

If any of these steps are missing, the dismissal may be considered unfair.

Fair reasons for dismissal

Not every dismissal is unfair. Employment law recognises several potentially fair reasons for dismissal.

These include:

  • Misconduct — such as breaches of company rules
  • Capability or performance — where an employee cannot meet required standards
  • Redundancy — where the role is no longer required
  • Statutory restriction — where continuing employment would break the law
  • Some other substantial reason (SOSR) — such as business reorganisation

Even where one of these reasons exists, the employer must still follow a fair process.

You can learn more about disciplinary procedures in our guide to
Facing a Disciplinary Hearing? Here's What to Expect.

When can a dismissal be unfair?

There are several situations where a dismissal may be considered unfair.

These include:

  • no proper investigation before dismissal
  • no disciplinary hearing
  • not giving you a chance to respond
  • failing to follow the employer’s own procedures
  • inconsistent treatment compared with other employees
  • making a decision without reasonable evidence

Even if the employer had a potentially fair reason, the dismissal may still be unfair if the process was not handled properly.

Understanding whether the correct procedure was followed is often key to assessing whether a dismissal was fair.

Automatically unfair dismissal

Some reasons for dismissal are considered automatically unfair. In these situations, employees may not need two years of service to bring a claim.

Common examples include dismissal because of:

  • pregnancy or maternity leave
  • whistleblowing
  • raising a grievance
  • trade union membership or activity
  • asserting a legal right (such as requesting minimum wage)
  • discrimination based on protected characteristics

These cases are treated particularly seriously.

If you were dismissed after raising a complaint or grievance, our guide to
How the Grievance Procedure Works in Scotland
may be helpful.

The importance of the ACAS Code in unfair dismissal cases

The ACAS Code of Practice on disciplinary and grievance procedures plays an important role in unfair dismissal claims.

Employment tribunals expect employers to follow the standards set out in the Code when handling disciplinary issues.

If an employer fails to follow the Code without good reason, a tribunal may:

  • find the dismissal unfair
  • increase compensation by up to 25%

You can learn more in our guide to
The ACAS Code of Practice Explained Simply.

Common examples of unfair dismissal

Some workplace situations frequently lead to unfair dismissal claims.

Examples include:

  • being dismissed without warning
  • being dismissed without investigation
  • being dismissed immediately after raising concerns
  • dismissal without a disciplinary hearing
  • redundancy processes that are unfair or rushed
  • dismissal based on weak or unreliable evidence

Every case is different, but these examples often raise concerns about fairness.

Unfair dismissal time limits

If you believe you have been unfairly dismissed, it is very important to check the time limits.

In most cases, you must:

  • start the process within three months minus one day from the date your employment ended
  • notify ACAS before making an employment tribunal claim

This deadline is strict, and missing it can prevent your claim from being heard.

Because of this, acting promptly is extremely important.

What to do if you think you have been unfairly dismissed

If you suspect your dismissal was unfair, taking early steps can help protect your position.

Useful steps include:

  • checking your dismissal date
  • requesting written reasons for dismissal
  • reviewing your employer’s disciplinary procedure
  • gathering relevant documents
  • keeping copies of correspondence
  • seeking advice if you are unsure about your rights

Many employees find it helpful to review what happened leading up to the dismissal.

If you went through a disciplinary process, our guide to
Facing a Disciplinary Hearing? Here's What to Expect
may help clarify what should have happened.

Unfair dismissal preparation checklist

If you are considering taking action after dismissal, this checklist may help you organise your information.

You may want to gather:

  • your contract of employment
  • dismissal letters
  • disciplinary correspondence
  • investigation documents
  • witness details
  • emails or messages relevant to your case
  • notes from meetings

Having organised records makes it easier to understand your position and explain what happened.

The employment tribunal process

If the matter cannot be resolved directly with your employer, you may be able to bring a claim to an employment tribunal.

Tribunals are independent bodies that resolve disputes between employers and employees.

The process usually involves:

  • notifying ACAS
  • attempting early conciliation
  • submitting a tribunal claim
  • preparing evidence
  • attending a hearing if required

Many cases settle before reaching a full hearing.

Understanding the process can make it feel less intimidating.

Support is available

Being dismissed can affect your confidence, finances, and wellbeing. It is completely normal to feel angry, anxious, or uncertain about the future.

Many employees across Scotland — including those in Glasgow, Edinburgh, and surrounding areas — experience uncertainty following dismissal.

Understanding your rights and exploring your options early can help you feel more in control during a difficult time.

How Ark Advocacy can help

If you believe you have been unfairly dismissed, professional support can help you understand your situation and prepare your next steps.

Ark Advocacy can help you:

  • review dismissal paperwork
  • understand disciplinary procedures
  • organise your documents
  • prepare for meetings or appeals
  • support you through grievance or appeal processes

You may also find these guides helpful:

FAQ

How long do I have to claim unfair dismissal?

In most cases, you must begin the process within three months minus one day from the date your employment ended.

Do I need two years of service to claim unfair dismissal?

Most employees need two years of service, but some dismissals are automatically unfair and do not require this.

Can I be dismissed without warning?

In serious misconduct cases, dismissal without prior warning may be possible. However, there should still be a fair investigation and hearing.

What is automatically unfair dismissal?

This refers to dismissal for specific protected reasons, such as pregnancy, whistleblowing, or raising concerns about workplace safety.

Can compensation be increased if procedures were not followed?

Yes. If an employer fails to follow the ACAS Code, a tribunal may increase compensation by up to 25%.

Related articles

Disclaimer: This article provides general information and is not legal advice. Employment situations are fact-specific, and strict time limits can apply.